How To Make A Strawberry Milkshake Without Ice Cream

As an Amazon Associate, I can earn from qualifying purchases. Learn More

What is your favorite milkshake? Do you even know how to make a shake? I make my own milkshakes. And yes, I have a special spot for smashed strawberry sweetness. I even know how to make a strawberry milkshake without ice cream!

That’s right. When my heart has a craving for the cold snack, I always have them. It doesn’t concern me if my icebox has some sitting ice cream or not. All that matters is strawberries because I love them raw and fresh as well. The rest of the ingredients is also not an issue as my kitchen cabinet has countless substitutes to use.

Also, my classic Vitamix is all well and alive too. So, I basically have got everything to make a delicious and creamy strawberry milkshake that Five Guys charge $5. Best of all, I can drink to my fill when my nieces are not with me.

Should You Drink Milkshake every day?

Assuming I’m right, I think the real question here is whether there’s anything bad in drinking milkshakes regularly.
For sure, a milkshake is that one snack you can’t really beat. It’s a two-in-one beverage that allows you to enjoy the pleasure of a dessert and that of a drink.

How To Make A Strawberry Milkshake Without Ice Cream

In the drink part, the shake packs various nutritive values, albeit most people don’t actually see it. If it’s the main ingredient- milk, you or your child can benefit a lot from its rich protein. Thus, assisting in boosting bone development and also building muscles if you do work out.

Also, milkshakes contain table sugar or honey, both of which are great sources of energy for the brain and cells. If you’re using fruit sugar, then your milkshake will also have rich vitamin C that will help combat diseases and boost immune system functions.

Still, the fruits that you add to your shakes share their respective nutritional benefits with the drink. If it’s our strawberries, for example, the cold dessert will also supplement fiber and high levels of antioxidants. Thus, assist in curbing the risk of heart disease, constipation, diabetes, some carcinogens, and the list goes on.

So, when you hear that faint voice deep down wants a milkshake, don’t think of it as just a refreshing drink. Take it as a chance to add your body with extra vitamins and minerals. However, remember not to exceed the fats and sugars ratio as you will now comprise the healthy aspect of the sweet snack

How To Make A Strawberry Milkshake Without Ice Cream

Even with the various health benefits, a basic milkshake is just a drink of milk, ice cream, and flavorings (like fruit/ chocolate syrup). Ice cream is the characteristic ingredient, whereby it brings out that cold feel and defines how thick the blend will be.

But if you didn’t have ready ice cream at the time your body was crying for a milkshake, there’s nothing to worry about. You can still have your choice shake flavor by replacing the real ice cream with its regular ingredients. That’s milk or cream, sugar, and ice.

So, if it’s our strawberry milkshake, you can go with ingredients like milk, table sugar, vanilla extra, whipped cream, and frozen strawberries.

How To Make A Strawberry Milkshake Without Ice Cream

When I last made this recipe, however, I also substituted the sugar for honey. It was still super delicious and a bit more smooth from the sticky syrup. You could try it as well and share with us which you feel have more authentic flavor compared to table sugar.

Without keeping you waiting, here is the simple recipe I used for my Creamy Sweet Vanilla strawberry milkshake. Hopefully, you’ll like and share with others.

Recipe: Creamy Sweet Vanilla Strawberry Milkshake

Serve Time: Breakfast, Lunch, Early Evening Snack
Cuisine: American
Serving Size: 2
Prep Time: 5 Minutes
Calories: Approx. 250
Nutrition: Sugar, Fat, Protein, Fiber, Cholesterol, Fiber, antioxidants


  • ½ cup whole milk
  • I tablespoon honey
  • 1/4 teaspoon vanilla extract
  • 5 frozen strawberries
  • Whipped cream (optional)
  • Ice cubes (optional)

You’ll also need to have a blender to break down the solid ingredients and help every other thing mix thoroughly. Either a regular or high-power model can do the work as long it won’t leave fruit chunks undissolved.


  • Place all the ingredients into your blender container in the listed order (Liquid first and frozen fruits last).
  • Set the variable knob to the lowest “1” setting
  • Turn the machine on and slowly raise the speed to variable 10
  • Blend the mixture for about 30 seconds or until smooth. If you notice the milkshake is not thick as you want it, add some ice and continue blending. You can use the tamper to push the stubborn fruit chunks or ice into the blades
  • Turn the machine off and serve in the glass while still thick. If desired, you can spread a layer of frosting, fresh strawberries, or any other favorite toppings.

Please Note
You can also fresh strawberries for your shake if you don’t have frozen ones. However, you’ll need to use real heavy whipping cream so that you can have a thicker shake. Otherwise, your refreshing drink will be nothing more than a vanilla strawberry smoothie.

Also, it’s worth mentioning ice is not the best thickener when it comes to milkshakes. Yes, you’ll get that denser texture at first but it will be temporary as the ice will start melting and thin the shake.

Must You Have A Blender To Prepare This Recipe?

In this strawberry milkshake, you require fresh or frozen strawberries for the blend. So, there’s no exception to using a blending machine. Otherwise, how else will you be able to break apart the fruits and ensure they mix thoroughly with the milk and the rest of the ingredients.

Anyway, here are three great options that you may like if you don’t have or would like to replace your blender.

Vitamix 5200 Classic Countertop Blender

q? encoding=UTF8&ASIN=B008H4SLV6&Format= SL250 &ID=AsinImage&MarketPlace=US&ServiceVersion=20070822&WS=1&tag=blenderspro 20&language=en USir?t=blenderspro 20&language=en US&l=li3&o=1&a=B008H4SLV6

Main Features:

  • High-power motor and hardened stainless blades
  • Variable speed control setting
  • Tornado blending style
  • Tall, slender 64-oz container
  • Tamper and removable lid plug

Although pricey, this machine is the best upgrade you can have in your kitchen. No, it doesn’t have preset programs but everything else you need to make a milkshake is available.

If it’s power, the blender packs a 2 horsepower motor that you can use in blending nearly any materials. The model is what I have in my kitchen until now and I can attest it ‘s a great investment. This will be my third year using the machine but up to this point, the motor has never smoked or stalled despite blending ice regularly.

Another great feature that comes in handy when making milkshakes with frozen fruits is the ability to use a tamper. Even if the blending container can do the cyclonic-type of blending, my shakes are mostly thick. So, sometimes I’ve to help and press the ingredients clinging near the sides into the blades.

Hamilton Beach 58148A Glass Jar Blender

q? encoding=UTF8&ASIN=B00EI7DPI0&Format= SL250 &ID=AsinImage&MarketPlace=US&ServiceVersion=20070822&WS=1&tag=blenderspro 20&language=en USir?t=blenderspro 20&language=en US&l=li3&o=1&a=B00EI7DPI0

Main Features:

  • Affordable
  • High impact glass jar
  • 700 watts motor
  • Dedicated pulse button
  • 5 buttons, 12 blending functions

At less than fifty, this blender no doubt is for anyone who would want to blend but the finances couldn’t allow it. It has a small but powerful motor that can chew everything you throw at it, though not as smooth as high-power Blendtec or Vitamix.

Like when making your smoothie, you might need to further chop down your fruits to ensure the machine blends well. If it’s frozen fruits or ice, you can try crushing them a little bit.

But the blender still has solid blades that even process using a patented wave-action style, which pulls the top materials towards the blades. So, you can have a smooth, creamy, and thick milkshake.

Even better, the blender comes with a glass jar that you may like if you don’t want plastic food containers in your kitchen.

Ps. Hamilton Beach was amongst the Drink mixer brands used in the 1910s for a milkshake.

Ninja BN701 Auto-iQ Smart Countertop Blender

q? encoding=UTF8&ASIN=B0855B5Z6F&Format= SL250 &ID=AsinImage&MarketPlace=US&ServiceVersion=20070822&WS=1&tag=blenderspro 20&language=en USir?t=blenderspro 20&language=en US&l=li3&o=1&a=B0855B5Z6F

Main Features:

  • 1400-watt motor with peak boost
  • Large 72-oz total crushing jar
  • Removable 6-blade assembly
  • Three preset programs
  • Three Speed Settings

Similarly, this blender has a reasonable price tag but a bit higher than the Hamilton Beach. If you have a taste of cool tech, the blender has a lovely, sleek design with multiple automated blending features.

Two of these smart programs are for crushing ice and making ice cream. So, the machine can come in handy at a time like that you don’t have ice cream at hand but your heart desires a tip of milkshake.

Also, the blender has the famed 6-blade system that the manufacturer introduced for dealing with ice and icy foods. So, you can work on your frozen strawberries like a pro. Only be careful with the blade unit as you can easily cut your finger.

Final Thoughts

To conclude, a milkshake is one of the deserts that you can bring together in under five minutes. It requires no special ingredients, other than that milk sitting in the fridge, sugar/ honey on the counter, and fruits from the freezer.

Even if it’s those times your nieces caught you by surprise, this article has discussed how you can make a sweet vanilla strawberry milkshake without ice cream. If you want to top your dessert drink with a healthier spin, you could add frozen bananas for potassium, vitamin B6, amongst other vitamins.

Leave a Comment